In Brawl, i love the final smashes, especially Luigi's final smash because it's incredibly hysterical to me for some reason (probably because during the smash a cornucopia of weed jokes result from onlookers) but overall, i'm gonna say Melee. Brawl just feels too flighty for my kind of playing style, and the Subspace Emissary wasn't something i particularly enjoyed playing through. And it lacks a ton of things Melee had, like the character unique target stages.