Melee Peach vs. Brawl Peach

[kinetic563]

Alright.

How many of you liked the way she was utilized in Brawl?

I. Did. Not.

It always frustrated me and it seemed as if my skills I had with Peach in Melee were gone in Brawl. I'm not one to get technical with this stuff, but I'm fairly certain what killed her for me was how much it took to rack damage to others and how difficult it was to K.O. someone. Brawl's slower-paced fighting also hindered my exp. using her.

That's why I hardly if ever used her(in Brawl) and stuck with Marth and Sonic. 'Twas a sad story, this one.

 

[Timmy]

Yeah I know that she got a huge nerf, but I still find her usable and fun to play. Plus I LOVE her Up Tilt (the Heart Bash).

The only thing I thought that needed nerfing from her Melee part was her Down Smash (that thing could do 88% fully charged on a heavy and it was her answer to everything ), but Brawl just ruined that move a LOT.

Her other aspects were also pretty bad; slower air speed, SERIOUS decrease in KO Power (I miss her Forward Throw that could actually KO), and going from one of the biggest double jumps to tied for the shortest Double Jump. These were really unnecessary nerfs, especially the lack of KO Power. Her "buffs" don't really compensate for her nerfs.

I also didn't really like her personality in Brawl; she seemed more like a granny (the way she walked and also her "LA-LA-LA-LA-LA" taunt). =P

So in the end, I prefer Melee Peach (and I'm sure many others do). Don't get me wrong though, I still enjoy Brawl's Peach.

 

[MQJinx]

I prefer Melee Peach by far, she's faster and way more powerful than in Brawl.

 

[deadlyximpulse]

Melee Peach by far, she just kick too much ass in Melee and she is perfectly balance.

The only thing I thought that needed nerfing from her Melee part was her Down Smash (that thing could do 88% fully charged on a heavy and it was her answer to everything ), but Brawl just ruined that move a LOT.

That's only if the opponent is crouch canceling like an idiot.

 

[CaptainShyguy]

Melee Peach was so much much much better. Easier to use and better balanced. She was also one of my main in Melee and I sure had a lot of fun with her, kicking some....

Anyways, Brawl's Peach isn't that bad. I don't use her as much unfortunately.