Well, it doesn't have to be a new game right? On the Nintendo side, even if it goes a bit repetitive, like we did for many series, we could take games from a series. (Example the Pokemon board and months after came the Pokemon XY board) You know what I mean?
A couple of suggestions, I know some of these games are kinda covered in some way in past months:
- Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door (I know there's the Paper Mario board, but it's barely 2 pages of topics for 3 games (at the time) and this game has a lot to be discussed on)
- Wind Waker (True, again there's the big board on the whole Zelda series, but with Wind Waker HD I think it could be a good go)
- Diddy Kong Racing (It was a really popular game for its time and some people liked this game better than MK64. There was also the remake for DS which was pretty nice and filled with nostalgia)
- Sonic Unleashed (Not the most popular game from the Sonic series I agree, still I feel there could be good discussion on this)
- Star Fox (it could either be the whole series, or personally for me it'd be 64. Again the remake on the 3DS kinda helps. Plus, I don't see any board for Star Fox)
- Yoshi's Story (Unfortunately I never really played this game, but from what I played it was good and pretty cute game. Perhaps some people on the forum know more from it than I do?)
- Majora's Mask (One of the most requested remakes of this generation. Personally, I never played it, but I do know some good stuff about it)
- Super Smash Bros Brawl (Probably not my best choice knowing we will get the WiiU and 3DS games by the end of this year, but it could work pretty well. I know a lot of members play this game so maybe)
- Bayonetta (or would it be better to wait for 2? it could work idk, I never played it though...)
If not from Nintendo, there are lots of games. I know many of these aren't the most popular in the forum, so I would suggest the whole series for most of these instead of focusing on one game: Assassin's Creed, God Of War, Tomb Raider, Infamous, Call of Duty (well many people hate it but why not lmao), GTA, Need For Speed, Little Big Planet, Uncharted, Jak & Daxter, Devil May Cry.