Mario Party Legacy Forum

Mario Party Legacy Forum => Forum Archive => Activities Central => Topic started by: Bowser498 on July 10, 2015

Title: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 10, 2015
This is the place where the game will start. NOTE: This first post here does not start the game! Sign-ups are still open here (http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=15202.msg296316#new).
Because we have 11 people signed up, here are the roles:
-1 King Boo
-1 Boo
-1 Mario
-1 Peach
-4 Toads (2 will be Super Toads)
-1 Yoshi
-1 Bowser
-1 Luigi

(If there are...
12 people: +1 Boo
13 people: +1 Toad [NOT SUPER TOAD !])

Here are the possible roles:

Mario:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Peach:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Boo:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

King Boo:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Toad:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Super Toad:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Bowser:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Luigi:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: RobinFTW on July 10, 2015
(Sorry for being annoying with questions :P)
Hm, well, if Bowser want to kill someone at night, he can't vote during the day, but if he didn't vote, everyone will know that he's Bowser, so they will vote to lynch him... right? Unless you still can say "No lynch" as Bowser during the day.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 10, 2015
(Sorry for being annoying with questions :P)
Hm, well, if Bowser want to kill someone at night, he can't vote during the day, but if he didn't vote, everyone will know that he's Bowser, so they will vote to lynch him... right? Unless you still can say "No lynch" as Bowser during the day.
Yeah, that could be taken into consideration for the other players.
(and I highly doubt if everybody will vote lol)
But yeah, I'll change that a bit.
Edit: Actually, that person can just lynch each day. (or say no lynch) They don't have to kill for the whole game if they don't want to. :P
(And obviously, I won't be saying what kind of person killed people throughout the night)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 13, 2015
NOTE: Because on Iwata's death, I am actually postponing this until July 15th, 2015.
Please sign up if you haven't already!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 13, 2015
Here is just my post that will start the game pretty much. :p   Plot will be in next post.
How will I be picking roles? When we have all the people, I will count the # of people and then reveal it. That number will be the different # of roles. You will then give me a number 1-(total number of people), and a number corresponds with a different role. Thing is, you don't know what number corresponds with each role. This is 1st come, 1st serve, starting July 15th @ 12 AM EST.
Remember: I will PM you the role; after you get it, tell me on this thread that you got the role. Once everybody tells me that you got your role via a PM, the game (starting on Night 0) will start.

People with night roles:

Mario: Will communicate with me each night in a secret spot, telling me who he wants to investigate.
Yoshi: Will communicate with me ONLY ONCE in a secret spot throughout the game, telling me on that night when he wants to be protected.
Peach: Will communicate with me each night in a secret spot, telling me who "she" wants to save that night.
Boos and King Boo: Will communicate with me each night or alone in a secret spot, discussing who they want to kill, and King Boo telling me who he wants to kill.

I will also be telling Luigi if there is one who Mario decided to investigate, and the results.

Edit: Actually, I'm gonna start on Day 1 instead of Night 0 so everybody will have a fair chance... 8)

CONTESTANTS:   STATUS/TIME KILLED:   ROLE:

Accj21                                     Alive                       (Role N/A)
BossBlitz (replaced Geo)    Alive                       (Role N/A)
RafalRib                     Dead: Lynched Day 3     (Super Toad) :toad:
RafalRib: REVIVED               Alive                        (Role N/A)
Sashe2705                 Dead: Killed Night 2       (Toad) :toad:
NintendoFan                             Alive                       (Role N/A)
Spike                         Dead: Lynched Day 4      (Bowser) :koopakid:
WiiUFan-04            Dead: Lynched Day 5          (Boo)   :kingboo:
RobinFTW               Dead: Killed Night 6             (Mario) :mario:
SmashBoo              Dead: Killed Night 4              (Yoshi) :yoshi:
Brookelas               Dead: Modkilled Day 5          (Luigi) :luigi:
SputnicK                                     Alive                       (Role N/A)
Everyday Luma                       Alive                        (Role N/A)
(was Day 6 clone)
Clone 1                                       Alive                          (Role N/A)
Clone 3                                       Alive                          (Role N/A)


*this post will have several major edits except the plot*
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 15, 2015
Okay, so now the game starts! Give me a number 1-11 on this thread, and I will PM you the role that corresponds with that number. Remember, that number needs to be open and not already taken by someone! Choose wisely!

This is 1st come, 1st serve
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: T367r4guj53iocioerj on July 15, 2015
I pick 5? I hope its an easy role
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 15, 2015
Picks:
1: Sashe2705
2: SmashBoo
3: Spike
4: WiiUFan-04
5: Geoman
6: RobinFTW
7: SputnicK
8: Accj21
9: NintendoFan
10: RafalRib
11: Brookelas
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: SputnicK on July 15, 2015
I choose 7.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: RobinFTW on July 15, 2015
Taking number 6!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Gizmo on July 15, 2015
I'll take 1.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 15, 2015
I guess I'll take 4.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Accj21 on July 15, 2015
I'll take #8!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 15, 2015
I will take number 3.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: NintendoFan on July 15, 2015
I'll go with nine.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 15, 2015
Okay, only Brookelas and SmashBoo remain! Pick your number!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: SmashBoo on July 15, 2015
I'll take 2.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 15, 2015
I'll take 2.
Okay! This leaves Brookelas at #11!

Here is a refresher on rules:
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Story: Day 1:

It was a dark and stormy day in the Mushroom Kingdom. 11 of the citizens: Accj, Raf, Sashe, Geoman, WiiUFan, Spike, Brookelas, SputnicK, SmashBoo, Robin, and NintendoFan, were chosen to compete in a mafia round to win 1 million coins for themselves and the team. But what they knew was that they were turned into Mario characters---if somebody died for any reason, it would reveal their true identity. But what they didn't know who was who: who was on the mafia and who wasn't. All of the townies decided to play their game at Peach's Castle, because it was nearly 200 feet away. But not only that, but they all saw Dark Bowser come. They all knew that he would kill all of them in a blink of an eye! So they all dashed into Peach's Castle, safe from Dark Bowser. The main thing they noticed was that there was no other people inside the castle except for them: was this a trap? A few minutes after they arrived, the group heard a "BAM" and a "BOOM" repetitively. When Geoman decided to look at the window, he noticed a BIG and BLACK cloud surrounding the castle. He shrieked in fright, with all the other members of the pack screaming in fright, all curled up into a ball. They all decided to go into the next room: a room with bunk beds. Then Spike gave a suggestion, and said that we need to figure out who was responsible for this, and who was on the mafia trying to conquer the Mushroom Kingdom. So they all decided to attempt to lynch daily...

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

IMPORTANT LYNCHING RULES:

-Always leave your vote bolded, or else it won't count.
-If you don't want to lynch somebody, just say "No Lynch".
-If you want to lynch somebody else (if changing your mind), just make a NEW post and say who you want to lynch/not lynch at all
-If you are Bowser and decide to kill somebody instead and not take part in voting (don't say who you are!), just don't vote. You can only kill once. If you decide to kill that night, then you can still take part in conversations, as long as it doesn't involve your vote.

(If you did not get your role PM, just tell me on this thread or PM me)

-GAME STARTS NOW-
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: RafalRib on July 15, 2015
*Suspects Spike for giving a suggestion*
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 15, 2015
I... honestly don't know what to do now.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: RafalRib on July 15, 2015
I... honestly don't know what to do now.

Neither :P I guess we should wait till tomorrow for more info

Vote: No Lynch
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: RobinFTW on July 15, 2015
Suspecting Brookelas because he didn't choose his number (worst reason ever, but whatever). (Don't take it personal :P)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 15, 2015
I... honestly don't know what to do now.

Neither :P I guess we should wait till tomorrow for more info

Vote: No Lynch
Alright then.

I'm going to suspect Sashe2705 for now. He looks suspicious.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 15, 2015
I... honestly don't know what to do now.
Try suspecting people, being active in the conversations like Raf, lynching, etc.
(Next time, just PM me your question. :))

No Lynch: 7 (RafalRib, Geoman, NintendoFan, Accj21, SmashBoo, Sashe, SputnicK)
Brookelas: 2 (RobinFTW, WiiUFan-04)
(sorry but I missed you SputnicK)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: T367r4guj53iocioerj on July 15, 2015
NO LYNCH
I will wait tomorrow
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 15, 2015
I vote Brookelas!

See you guys tomorrow!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: RobinFTW on July 15, 2015
I vote Brookelas!
You have to put your vote in bold :P
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 15, 2015
I vote Brookelas!

See you guys tomorrow!
I'll let it fly, but make sure to bold your vote next time!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: SputnicK on July 15, 2015
NO LYNCH
I will wait tomorrow
Hmm.... Maybe your not lynching because your a mafia and don't need to look for the bad guys!
LYNCH GEOMAN
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: NintendoFan on July 15, 2015
Guys it's day one and we're already lynching people? What if they are innocent?

No lynch
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Accj21 on July 15, 2015
From being in Slacker's mafia, I agree: To keep the innocent alive, I vote
NO LYNCH.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: SmashBoo on July 15, 2015
It's the first day, I don't a reason to lynch yet so I vote NO LYNCH
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: SputnicK on July 15, 2015
I dunno he seemed fishy...
Fine
NO LYNCH
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Gizmo on July 16, 2015
Suspecting Brookelas because he didn't choose his number (worst reason ever, but whatever). (Don't take it personal :P)
I'm going to suspect Sashe2705 for now. He looks suspicious.
I vote Brookelas!
NO LYNCH
I will wait tomorrow
Hmm.... Maybe your not lynching because your a mafia and don't need to look for the bad guys!
LYNCH GEOMAN

These just don't make any sense and you don't have any evidence behind your votes.

But it's still Day 1, so Vote: No Lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME-
Post by: Bowser498 on July 16, 2015
Day 1: No Lynch:
The crew today decided not to lynch, not knowing what was coming that night. They all got tired of accusing each other, with some blaming Brookelas, others blaming Sashe. At 9 PM, they decided to hit the hay. The big, puffy dark cloud was still outside the castle to make it impossible to escape.

It is now Night 1. Everybody with night roles, please send me your actions. Please no talking during nighttime.

People with night actions:
Mario, Yoshi (ONCE THROUGH GAME), Bowser (ONCE THROUGH GAME), Peach, Boo + King Boo
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 1)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 16, 2015
Night 1:
At about 7 AM, Accj and Geoman decided to wake up. Accj told Geoman that he had a weird dream of somebody being saved. Then, Accj did role count. Geoman and Sashe volunteered to help.
Spoiler: Role Count (click to show/hide)

It is now Day 2. With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch, once again. :P
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: RafalRib on July 16, 2015
*suspects Accj for doing role count*
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 16, 2015
I think I'm gonna Lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: RafalRib on July 16, 2015
I think I'm gonna Lynch.
Lynch who? :P
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 16, 2015
I think I'm gonna Lynch.
Lynch who?

*suspects Accj for doing role count*
Raf, once again, these are just for examples to make the story more interesting... :P


Just an update:
At the end of the game, there will be awards like (computer cuts me off)
Oops, you'll just have to wait and see!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: RafalRib on July 16, 2015
Raf, once again, these are just for examples to make the story more interesting... :P
Once again Bow Wow, I'm just spicing up things LOL
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: NintendoFan on July 16, 2015
I think Mario should claim because 1. He should be able to tell us if he got a boo/mafia and 2. Peach would be able to protect Mario every night.

Don't have any scum reads at the moment but we'll see as the day progresses.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Accj21 on July 16, 2015
Nice job, whoever Peach is!  :)
Again, I think we should go with
NO LYNCH.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 16, 2015
Sashe
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: RafalRib on July 16, 2015
Nice job, whoever Peach is!  :)

That sounded a bit suspicious LOL
But yeah we should go with No Lynch
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 16, 2015
Day 2 Votes:
No Lynch: 6 (Accj21, RafalRib, WiiUFan, RobinFTW, NFan, SmashBoo)
Sashe: 1 (RLWilliams3d)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 1)
Post by: Yoshiman222 on July 16, 2015
Night 1:
At about 7 AM, Accj and Geoman decided to wake up. Accj told Geoman that he had a weird dream of somebody being saved. Then, Accj did role count. Geoman and Sashe volunteered to help.
Spoiler: Role Count (click to show/hide)

It is now Day 2. With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch, once again. :P
Don't mean to intrude much but if you're going to include others names in the story, it's best to only do so if somethings happens publicly that's related to them (aka they die/role revealed/public role action), or else you get random comments about those people being randomly selected in the story. You can always use the term "someone" remember.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Accj21 on July 16, 2015
I think Mario should claim because 1. He should be able to tell us if he got a boo/mafia and 2. Peach would be able to protect Mario every night.

Don't have any scum reads at the moment but we'll see as the day progresses.

I agree. It would really help the town.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 1)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 16, 2015
Night 1:
At about 7 AM, Accj and Geoman decided to wake up. Accj told Geoman that he had a weird dream of somebody being saved. Then, Accj did role count. Geoman and Sashe volunteered to help.
Spoiler: Role Count (click to show/hide)

It is now Day 2. With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch, once again. :P
Don't mean to intrude much but if you're going to include others names in the story, it's best to only do so if somethings happens publicly that's related to them (aka they die/role revealed/public role action), or else you get random comments about those people being randomly selected in the story. You can always use the term "someone" remember.
Yes, that is true. (NOTE that it is for fun and has nothing to do with the game. Remember, like Raf said, it's to spice up the game. :P)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 16, 2015
Don't feel like attacking any one right now, so...

No Lynch
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Accj21 on July 16, 2015
Don't feel like attacking any one right now, so...

Legit reasoning right there.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 16, 2015
I think I should vote for No Lynch, because there's not enough suspicious activities yet...
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: NintendoFan on July 16, 2015
Yeah I think i'm just going to vote for No Lynch like everyone else
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: SmashBoo on July 16, 2015
*suspects SputnicK and WiiU-Fan for being surprised for everyone being in the room*

Still, NO LYNCH
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Yoshiman222 on July 16, 2015
Night 1:
At about 7 AM, Accj and Geoman decided to wake up. Accj told Geoman that he had a weird dream of somebody being saved. Then, Accj did role count. Geoman and Sashe volunteered to help.
Spoiler: Role Count (click to show/hide)

It is now Day 2. With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch, once again. :P
Don't mean to intrude much but if you're going to include others names in the story, it's best to only do so if somethings happens publicly that's related to them (aka they die/role revealed/public role action), or else you get random comments about those people being randomly selected in the story. You can always use the term "someone" remember.
Yes, that is true. (NOTE that it is for fun and has nothing to do with the game. Remember, like Raf said, it's to spice up the game. :P)
*suspects SputnicK and WiiU-Fan for being surprised for everyone being in the room*
This comment is exactly what I mean by this.

*leaves before Bowser gets mad at this intrusion.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: SputnicK on July 16, 2015
*suspects SputnicK and WiiU-Fan for being surprised for everyone being in the room*

Still, NO LYNCH
WHAT?? When did I say that???

We need to lynch else the mafia pick us off one by one. I really am at a loss on who is evil and who isn't, but I agree WiiUFan is suspicious.
Lynch WiiUFan-04
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 16, 2015
Day 2: No Lynch

The group, once again, decided not to lynch due to the lack of activity. At about 5 PM, a few Toads decided to go food shopping. Although they all came back safely, a Toad found this news bulletin:
Spoiler: Day 2 News Bulletin (click to show/hide)

After, the lights go out, and all of the pack shriek in fright. Then they hear an echo from within the castle walls:
"Hahaha! You know what I just did! I used the "Non-name Generator", so none of your names will be featured in these stories. You can all thank Yoshiman222 for that! BWAHAHAHA!"

Everybody: What is going on?
Yoshiman from phone:  "...is...Boo.......night 1........." *voice ends*
Everybody was unsure of what just happened, and why certain parts of the message were cut off.

It is now Dawn of Night 2. Dawn is still daytime, but here you can still talk about your suspicions and ideas. You cannot revote during dawn.

And Yoshiman, those were used to spice up the game. It wasn't used to make other people suspect on them. The people there have nothing to do with the actual game...
(Sorry SputnicK, but I didn't get to count it because a majority, which was 6/11 people, has been made.  :-\)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Accj21 on July 16, 2015

We need to lynch else the mafia pick us off one by one. I really am at a loss on who is evil and who isn't, but I agree WiiUFan is suspicious.
Lynch WiiUFan-04
Mathematically speaking, that has a 73% of hitting town. Same with you, RLWilliams3D.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 2)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 16, 2015
Dawn of Day 2:
Well, nobody was worried about the warning note by Dark Bowser, and the cut off message from Yoshiman. What did the message mean? And what was Dark Bowser's warning all about?

It is now Night 2. Everybody with night roles, send them to me! Remember, no talking!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 2)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 17, 2015
Night 2:
All felt well for everybody. The last Toad fell asleep near 10 PM, not knowing what would happen. Everybody had terrifying dreams of the mafia killing them, their friends, or their fellow townies. However, in the morning, all was well. Except for the fact that a body was face down in the middle of the main bedroom. One of the Toads decided to turn it over in order to reveal the true identity of the body.

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

It is now Day 3. With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RafalRib on July 17, 2015
*Suspects Sashe for dying*
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: SmashBoo on July 17, 2015
Best suspection ever, Raf XP
*suspects RafalRib for suspecting a dead person of killing himself*
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: T367r4guj53iocioerj on July 17, 2015
Best suspection ever, Raf XP
*suspects RafalRib for suspecting a dead person of killing himself*
I agree too Suspects RAF
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 17, 2015
Day 3 Lynch Poll:
RafalRib: 6 (Geoman, RobinFTW, WiiUFan-04, SputnicK, SmashBoo, Spike)
Geoman: 1 (RafalRib)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 17, 2015
I vote RafalRib :P
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 17, 2015
Lynching RafalRib for now.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: SputnicK on July 17, 2015
I'm really conflicted about who is suspicious and who's not. Here's my thoughts so far:

Accj21 I don't suspect at the moment, as he has contributed and said nothing suspicious yet.
Geoman IDK about him right now
RafalRib is middle ground? I don't know.
NintendoFan seems a little fishy.
Spike has contributed nothing, making him a prime mafia suspect.
WiiUFan-04 also seems fishy. He could be mafia.
RobinFTW is middle ground. Could be mafia though.
SmashBoo I do not suspect at the moment, as he has contributed.
Brookelas has said little. Mafia perhaps?
SputnicK is me. I can't prove to you guys that I'm not, so note your own thoughts on me.

What are your guys thoughts? I am lynching RafalRib until he provides some evidence otherwise.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: NintendoFan on July 17, 2015
I'm really conflicted about who is suspicious and who's not. Here's my thoughts so far:

Accj21 I don't suspect at the moment, as he has contributed and said nothing suspicious yet.
Geoman IDK about him right now
RafalRib is middle ground? I don't know.
NintendoFan seems a little fishy.
Spike has contributed nothing, making him a prime mafia suspect.
WiiUFan-04 also seems fishy. He could be mafia.
RobinFTW is middle ground. Could be mafia though.
SmashBoo I do not suspect at the moment, as he has contributed.
Brookelas has said little. Mafia perhaps?
SputnicK is me. I can't prove to you guys that I'm not, so note your own thoughts on me.

What are your guys thoughts? I am lynching RafalRib until he provides some evidence otherwise.

I was kinda busy all day, so I wasn't able to reply earlier when the day started...

Anyway, you seem to be town. My reads on everyone are pretty much the same as yours.

Also, someone named Spike was in the game? O.o Please, speak up now.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: Gizmo on July 18, 2015
:ghost: WiiUFan, Raf, RobinFTW and SputnicK all seem suspicious to me at the moment. Look at my last post.

http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=15211.msg296965#msg296965 (http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=15211.msg296965#msg296965)

Especially WiiUFan. Keep an eye on them, guys! Go, Toads! :-D
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 18, 2015
I'm Spike, NintendoFan. Also, sorry I didn't contributed last night. I went to bed early before the game started  -_-;
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RafalRib on July 18, 2015
Wait i woke up and everyone Lynches Me? XD

(Lynch me if you want, you'll regret killing one of your friends (Town))
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 18, 2015
Sorry, Raf. I didn't lynch you, but only because I didn't participate because I went to bed early. :P
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RafalRib on July 18, 2015
Lynching Geoman

Why would he start lynching me without reasons?
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 18, 2015
Why would he start lynching me without reasons?
We have to try to kill the Mafia before they kill the whole town, right? It's not by voting "No Lynch" every night that we'll get somewhere :P

BTW, when will the Night 3 start?
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RafalRib on July 18, 2015
Why would he start lynching me without reasons?
We have to try to kill the Mafia before they kill the whole town, right? It's not by voting "No Lynch" every night that we'll get somewhere :P

BTW, when will the Night 3 start?

You guys acting like mafia then, trying to kill a normal town guy
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 18, 2015
I'm really conflicted about who is suspicious and who's not. Here's my thoughts so far:

Accj21 I don't suspect at the moment, as he has contributed and said nothing suspicious yet.
Geoman IDK about him right now
RafalRib is middle ground? I don't know.
NintendoFan seems a little fishy.
Spike has contributed nothing, making him a prime mafia suspect.
WiiUFan-04 also seems fishy. He could be mafia.
RobinFTW is middle ground. Could be mafia though.
SmashBoo I do not suspect at the moment, as he has contributed.
Brookelas has said little. Mafia perhaps?
SputnicK is me. I can't prove to you guys that I'm not, so note your own thoughts on me.

What are your guys thoughts? I am lynching RafalRib until he provides some evidence otherwise.

I was kinda busy all day, so I wasn't able to reply earlier when the day started...

Anyway, you seem to be town. My reads on everyone are pretty much the same as yours.

Also, someone named Spike was in the game? O.o Please, speak up now.
Spike is RLWilliams3D, just his nickname on the site. :P

Night 3 will start after we get a majority.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 18, 2015
Just wanna note: Geoman is leaving for a bit starting tomorrow. If he doesn't die tonight, Yoshiman will take his place.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RafalRib on July 18, 2015
LOL I'll be the one dying tho
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 18, 2015
LOL I'll be the one dying tho
Maybe during the day. People can still change heir votes though!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: SmashBoo on July 18, 2015
Raf does suspect a lot so it's kinda suspicious and the majority is already above him so I lynch RafalRib
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: SputnicK on July 18, 2015
Why would he start lynching me without reasons?
We have to try to kill the Mafia before they kill the whole town, right? It's not by voting "No Lynch" every night that we'll get somewhere :P

BTW, when will the Night 3 start?
RobinFTW is right. The mafia will always kill a town person at night, but if we attack people we think are mafia we have almost a half chance of getting it right.

So lynching is important.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 18, 2015
Why would he start lynching me without reasons?
We have to try to kill the Mafia before they kill the whole town, right? It's not by voting "No Lynch" every night that we'll get somewhere :P

BTW, when will the Night 3 start?
RobinFTW is right. The mafia will always kill a town person at night, but if we attack people we think are mafia we have almost a half chance of getting it right.

So lynching is important.

I agree with you, SputnicK. :-)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 18, 2015
No Lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 18, 2015
No Lynch.

I change my mind. Lynch Raf :-/
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 3)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 18, 2015
Day 3:
The majority of the Toads decided to lynch the Hype God, AKA RafalRib. Everybody went up to the 5th floor of the castle to kill him. The three options of being killed were being hung, being shot, or getting tossed into a fire alive. Raf chose one of those three. His last words were "Please don't kill me. I wanna give everybody the HYPE!" Five minutes later, he was dead.
Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Soon after he was dead, the group heard repetitive lightning outside, and the cloud grew even bigger that it was coming within 50 feet of the outside of the castle. They were all trapped. No escaping was allowed, unless they wanted to buy a farm.

It is now Night 3. Everybody with night actions, please send me your actions. Remember, no talking, unless you are Sashe and Raf and want to talk about irrelevant topics not related to this mafia game.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 3)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 18, 2015
Sorry to interrupt but BossBlitz88 took Geoman's role. If Geo wins something, BB will also win.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 3)
Post by: RafalRib on July 19, 2015
Told ya guys, just making suspicions doesnt mean that person is mafia!

Besides, YOU CAN'T KILL THE HYPE! *vanishes*
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 3)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 19, 2015
Night 3:
Everybody plunged into a deep sleep. Thing was, some of the toads could hear some stabbing noises. One of the toads was screaming for help, but then everybody went back to sleep. Role count came in, and it totaled 9 people. What had happened?

Spoiler: Day 4 News Bulletin (click to show/hide)


It is now Day 4. With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 19, 2015
Stabbing noises, huh? To stab, we need a sharpy thing... like what? A knife, or even a spiky thing... SPIKE YOU'RE THE MAFIA! jk

Though, changing his mind like this while having 1h and 30 minutes between his past comment and his first vote is kind of suspicious...

Lynch Spike
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: Accj21 on July 19, 2015
I realized something! SputnicK gave person-by-person information, and Bowser498 did the same thing in Slacker's. Bowser498 was mafia. I think I am on to something here, so I will lynch SputnicK.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 19, 2015
RobinFTW I never thought of it like that XD

Day 4 Votes:
SputnicK: 1 (WiiUFan)
Spike: 5 (RobinFTW, NFan, BossBlitz88, Accj21, Spike)
WiiUFan-04: 1 (SputnicK)
RobinFTW: 1 (SmashBoo)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: NintendoFan on July 19, 2015
Lynch Spike. He barely talked all game. Just what a Mafia scum would do.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: BossBlitz on July 19, 2015
Hmmmm.....RobinFTW's too smart for our own good. He could be mafia. Judging Spike by name as a joke....I'll lynch RobinFTW.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 19, 2015
I realized something! SputnicK gave person-by-person information, and Bowser498 did the same thing in Slacker's. Bowser498 was mafia. I think I am on to something here, so I will lynch SputnicK.

Yeah maybe, but SputnicK wasn't even in Slacker's game. It's probably just a coincidence. It's smart though.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
Trust me, I'm innocent. I'm just getting used to using the forum  :-[
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 19, 2015
Lynching SputnicK for the same reasons as Accj21.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: BossBlitz on July 19, 2015
Trust me, I'm innocent. I'm just getting used to using the forum  :-[
I lynched Robin to keep the lynch votes spread but playing the newbie card? I change my lynch vote to Spike.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
How could you, BB? :-\
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 19, 2015
Trust me, I'm innocent. I'm just getting used to using the forum  :-[
I lynched Robin to keep the lynch votes spread but playing the newbie card? I change my lynch vote to Spike.

True, this makes you even more suspicious, Spike..
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
Trust me, I'm innocent. I'm just getting used to using the forum  :-[
I lynched Robin to keep the lynch votes spread but playing the newbie card? I change my lynch vote to Spike.

True, this makes you even more suspicious, Spike..
Look, I'm sorry I haven't been talking. I'm more used to talking on the site than on the forum. I just need to use the forum more. Honest.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
Well, to even the odds, I lynch SputnicK.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 19, 2015
Trust me, I'm innocent. I'm just getting used to using the forum  :-[
I lynched Robin to keep the lynch votes spread but playing the newbie card? I change my lynch vote to Spike.

True, this makes you even more suspicious, Spike..
Look, I'm sorry I haven't been talking. I'm more used to talking on the site than on the forum. I just need to use the forum more. Honest.
Don't take it personally, Spike. We don't have anything against you :) (I still don't change my vote though :P)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
Sorry, sorry. I'm nervous, though. Me and SputnicK only need to be lynched twice respectively before either of us are out. And I feel I'm gonna be out. :-[
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: SputnicK on July 19, 2015
I realized something! SputnicK gave person-by-person information, and Bowser498 did the same thing in Slacker's. Bowser498 was mafia. I think I am on to something here, so I will lynch SputnicK.
Really?? I didn't even join MPL until months after that mafia game happened. Please don't lynch on unrelated coincidences. (Or are you really that naive?)

I'm going to be honest I'm not sure if Spike is our guy either.  I do feel that he lynches with half-baked explanations, but that could just be his style.

One thing that really concerns me is Brookelas hasn't posted in days. Is that not typical mafia behavior? IDK, do what your going to do, I can't stop you. I just ask you to think before making any final decisions.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
I realized something! SputnicK gave person-by-person information, and Bowser498 did the same thing in Slacker's. Bowser498 was mafia. I think I am on to something here, so I will lynch SputnicK.
Really?? I didn't even join MPL until months after that mafia game happened. Please don't lynch on unrelated coincidences. (Or are you really that naive?)

I'm going to be honest I'm not sure if Spike is our guy either.  I do feel that he lynches with half-baked explanations, but that could just be his style.

One thing that really concerns me is Brookelas hasn't posted in days. Is that not typical mafia behavior? IDK, do what your going to do, I can't stop you. I just ask you to think before making any final decisions.

Oh, alright :P. If I'm gonna go out, I might as well with dignity. I resign with Lynch against SputnicK. No Lynch
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: SputnicK on July 19, 2015
Thanks Spike. TBH I don't think your mafia either. My current vote is WiiUFan-04 (the way he always goes with the crowd resembles the characteristics of a mafia)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 19, 2015
SmashBoo and Brookelas still haven't made their decisions. At 8 PM EST, if no majority has been made, whoever has the most votes (or if it's a No Lynch) will be the result of Day 4.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
Thanks Spike. TBH I don't think your mafia either. My current vote is WiiUFan-04 (the way he always goes with the crowd resembles the characteristics of a mafia)
Yeah, he could be. But IDK. I might as well go out with dignity, whether or not I'm Townie or Mafia.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: SmashBoo on July 19, 2015
I lynch RobinFTW, he's a smart guy and we need to be careful if he's Mafia, since the beginning we don't know much about him and he seems to be one of the first if not the first to lynch and he doesn't even says why. This can be a failed theory like most of mine, but still.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: Accj21 on July 19, 2015
Sorry I was off on my SputnicK theory. I am changing my vote to Lynching Spike.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
*Sigh* Let's just get this over with. I lynch myself. :what:
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 19, 2015
Day 4:

It was a very close lynch, some people going for Spike, others going for RobinFTW and SputnicK. However, several people revoted to go to Spike. Finally, Spike decided to lynch himself and give one up for the team; he thought it was the best thing to do. Everybody went up to the 5th floor to make the kill. Spike's last words were, "Whoever are the Boos, I wish to you good luck."

Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Spike, you can make one last (day) comment saying goodbye, even if it's in the night phase. After, you can talk about anything irrelevant to the game with your fellow "Dead Boos"

Shocked by the results, everybody was panicking. The cloud now looked about 25 feet away from the edge of the castle. Everybody was in fright as the cloud yelled like thunder.

It is now Night 4. Everybody with night actions, please send me your decisions. Remember, you cannot talk unless you would like to talk about irrelevant topics and you are either Spike, Raf, or Sashe.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: RafalRib on July 19, 2015
Finally! The "dead"ones are allowed to talk! XD

Wow he must be really desperate to die :P

Anyway welcome to Hell LOL
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 4)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 19, 2015
Finally! The "dead"ones are allowed to talk! XD

Wow he must be really desperate to die :P

Anyway welcome to Hell LOL


Hey Raf. So, how's death?
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 4)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 19, 2015
Finally! The "dead"ones are allowed to talk! XD

Wow he must be really desperate to die :P

Anyway welcome to Hell LOL
Also sorry to interrupt but once you're dead, you can talk during night phases. You could've talked the night after you died. :P
And let's just say with any role, you go to "Dreamy Mafia World" once you die. XP
-NIGHT PHASE CONTINUES-
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 4)
Post by: RafalRib on July 19, 2015
Hey Raf. So, how's death?
I dunno about you since i'm in Heaven, BURN IN HELL MAFIA!!!!!!!! LOL
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 4)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 19, 2015
Night 4:
It was a very slow night. They were all stuffed from their dinner, which was mushrooms and a side of pasta. As well as this, they were all bored, but hyped at winning the 1 million coins! Because one of the Toads was hungry, he went to get a bite to eat from the kitchen, when he heard the mafia discussing who they wanted to kill. He said, "Is it you...... *dies*" In the morning, they realized that somebody was gone. They had no worries, except for when they went down to the 5th floor for breakfast, one of the Toads noticed something in the kitchen next door. The oh-so-famous knife in its display "Cutty Cutie" was missing! Another Toad then found the knife on the floor, five feet from the bookshelves. When a toad brought the knife back, he slid it in its place. Then, everybody heard a repetitive beeping sound. The middle of the stove broke in half, and a new room opened. A body was lying in the middle of the room. There was also a script that read
"mall awky fiio illu!"
Not knowing what it meant, the toads took a closer look at the body.
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Spoiler: Day 5 News Bulletin (click to show/hide)

The Toads read the news bulletin, and they all rush down to Floor 2.



It is now Day 5. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 19, 2015
No one's doing any thing suspicious right now, so No Lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: NintendoFan on July 19, 2015
Mario, please claim if you have a Mafia inspect. We could really use it.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 19, 2015
Just a note, but the surveys must be done by Night 5! Please do it if you can, it will really affect the game in a positive way! ;)
REMEMBER: You don't have to answer every question if you don't want to.

Day 5 Votes:
No Lynch: 1 (WiiUFan)
WiiUFan: 3 (SputnicK, BossBlitz, RobinFTW)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: SputnicK on July 19, 2015
I'm sorry WiiUFan-04 is being so suspicious it hurts. Lynch WiiUFan-04

BTW where the heck is Brookelas??
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 19, 2015
I'm sorry WiiUFan-04 is being so suspicious it hurts. Lynch WiiUFan-04

BTW where the heck is Brookelas??
RobinFTW asked, and tbh I really don't know. XP
(I saw he was active today though... :-\)
I will say this: if he's on the mafia, he's not making the decisions. If he's a boo, then King Boo made all the decisions. But you can probably figure out something...
(BTW, if he's not active by night 5, he will be modkilled.)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 19, 2015
Survey's answers:
1. Nope
2. I honestly have no idea
3. Peach, because I think it'll be cool to save people.
4. Because it seemed to be an awesome game.
5. What is my role? I'm not answering this question, duuuuuuuuuuh :P
6. The mafia tried to kill the same person Peach protected.
7. ^Same thing^
8. "it is this Boo who.... tried to kill "him" during night 1"??? IDK
9. I KNOW
Spoiler (click to show/hide)
10. Yup, it's awesome :D
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 19, 2015
TBH, I would lynch Brookelas, but he'll be modkilled soon, so... I guess WiiUFan-04 because he's acting kind of suspicious. I mean, even if there's nothing really suspicious, in my opinion, like I said, you have to at least try to kill someone, because the mafia will win if we vote no lynch each day.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: BossBlitz on July 19, 2015
I lynch Wii U Fan. He could be trying to keep peace and let us all die leaving him. He could be Mafia.

Survey:
1.No
2. IDK
3. Bowser
4. I didn't
5. Mario....or is it Mario?
6. Not telling
7. Not telling
8. idk
9.
Spoiler (click to show/hide)
10. Fun but scary
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Accj21 on July 20, 2015
Survey:
1. Yes, Slacker's
2. I'm not sure.
3. I wish I was King Boo.
4. Because I enjoyed playing in Slacker's game.
5. Not sure why this is a question...
6. The mafia probably attacked someone who had immunity.
7. Ditto.
8. IDK
9. I think RobinFTW got it.
10. Yes.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 20, 2015

1. Have you ever played Mafia besides this game? Nope

2. Who do you think are the following roles?

Mario: Accj21
Peach: RobinFTW
Boo: SputnicK
King Boo: BossBlitz88

3. If you were to be any role in the game, what would you be? Yoshi

4. Why did you sign up? Idk

5. What is your role? That's none of your business

6. What do you think happened on Night 1? Idk

7. What do you think happened on Night 3? Idk

8. What is the full message for this: "...is...Boo.......night 1........."? Is Boo the guy from Night 1 who tried to kill us?

9. What does this code mean? "mall awky fiio illu!"? Idk

10. Are you having fun playing this? Yes.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Accj21 on July 20, 2015

2. Who do you think are the following roles?

Mario: Accj21

Will this end up getting me killed by the mafia tonight?  :P
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: SmashBoo on July 20, 2015
1. Have you ever played Mafia besides this game? No

2. Who do you think are the following roles? T

Mario: ????
Peach: ????
Boo: ????
King Boo: RobinFTW (I might be dead but my theory must live on)

3. If you were to be any role in the game, what would you be? I don't really know tbh, i like it random

4. Why did you sign up? It seemed fun

5. What is your role? Yoshi

6. What do you think happened on Night 1? Peach healed the same person who was going to be killed

7. What do you think happened on Night 3? It was a Super Toad

8. What is the full message for this: "...is...Boo.......night 1........."? Idk

9. What does this code mean? "mall awky fiio illu!"? RobinFTW solved it, I told you he's a smart guy xp

10. Are you having fun playing this? Yeah :D I want to play it again to see if I last longer :P

It is now Day 5. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 20, 2015
-ATTENTION! A BIG NOTE FROM DARK BOWSER AT 1:34 PM!-

Hahahaha! Looks like we got more than half of the people surviving! JUST WHAT I WANTED! BECAUSE ON DAY 6, SOMETHING BIG WILL HAPPEN! SOMETHING THAT WILL PROBABLY CHANGE THE ENTIRE GAME! BWAHAHAHAHA!

Feel free to post your reaction here...

Day 5 Continues
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 20, 2015
Screw you, Dark Bowser.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 20, 2015
Sooooooooo, where are the four people remaining for voting?
And I don't really know what to think about Dark Bowser, I'm just looking forward to see what will happen, lol.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 20, 2015
C'mon, please vote for Day 5 if you haven't already!

No Lynch: 1 (WiiUFan)
WiiUFan: 3 (SputnicK, BossBlitz, RobinFTW, NFan)
SputnicK: 1 (Accj21)
No Vote: Brookelas

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

(Robin there's 7 people, not 8. :P)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Accj21 on July 20, 2015
I still don't know about WiiUFan or SputnicK, but I think I will Vote SputnicK.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: NintendoFan on July 20, 2015
Lynch WiiUFan-04

That's hammer.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 20, 2015
(Robin there's 7 people, not 8. :P)
I was counting Brookelas :P
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 20, 2015
Day 5:
Almost everybody alive decided to vote for WiiUFan-04 because he was giving "suspicious" actions. Everybody went up to the lynching room, and his last words were "How the hell can I die when I'm already dead? ".
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

Surprised by his role, everybody kept suspecting each other, not knowing what Day 6 would bring them.
And yes, I had a gun and exactly when the other person was lynched in the lynching room, Brookelas was shot and killed because he decided not to participate.
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

It is Night 5. Everybody with a night vote, please send me your actions. Remember, no talking unless you are dead: lynched or killed. King Boo doesn't count!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 5)
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 20, 2015
I'm actually kinda glad I'm dead. Wanted an excuse to drop out of the game.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 5)
Post by: RafalRib on July 21, 2015
People in the game be like: SUDDENLY, BOW WOW IN THE GAME
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 5)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 21, 2015
HELLO ;D
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 5)
Post by: RafalRib on July 21, 2015
Still night here? LOL
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 5)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 21, 2015
Night 5:
Everybody was asleep in the blink of an eye: at 11:28 PM to be exact. Near 1 PM, everybody was in the exact same dream---how could this be? At first it looked like Accj was being killed, then NFan, then RobinFTW, then BB, then SputnicK. (the order doesn't matter BTW)
Even with these thoughts, it looked like in their dreams, they were illiterate. They could see sloppy words in the sky, but nobody knew what it was. Nobody could decipher it, probably because they were illiterate. Then, everybody (in the dream) heard a "CLASH' and a "CLANG", but nobody was killed. What had happened?

-DAY 6 NEWS BULLETIN-



It is now Day 6. With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.
No, I didn't forget about the clones... =P
it is Day 6. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: NintendoFan on July 21, 2015
Well then.

Mario? Still no mafia inspect?
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: MattC on July 21, 2015
HOW DO YOU STOP A SKIDDING CAR FROM CRASHING INTO THE MEDIAN?

ANSWER: MORE GAS.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: Accj21 on July 21, 2015
Hooray for us lynching a mafia member! Although I suppose now there could be more because of the clones. I have no idea who to lynch.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 21, 2015
Ooohhh that will spice the game up!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 21, 2015
Okay so there is 5 "real" people and 3 clones. There is 1 guilty person in the "real" people group and 2 guilty people in the clones group.

SO that means that:
-1/5 is guitly (Real People Group)
-2/3 is guilty (Clones group)

There's more chance of lynching a guilty person in the clones group, so I vote for CLONE 3!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 21, 2015
btw when I meant "part of the game", I meant if you participated, dead or alive.
Anyways, I got some quotes from the clones!

Clone 1:

Spoiler: Clone 1 (click to show/hide)
Clone 3:
Spoiler: Clone 3 (click to show/hide)

Day 6 Votes:
Clone 1: 4 (Clone 3, Accj21, Everyday Luma, SputnicK)
Clone 3: 4 (RobinFTW, Clone 1, Bossblitz88, NFan)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: BossBlitz on July 21, 2015
I LYNCH CLONE 3. Get this man out of here, the mafia is dangerous, but this is outrageous.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 21, 2015
BUT WAIT! THERE'S MORE! We have Dark Boo, from the sidelines, using the No-Clone generator!

So, all the toads were frightened after they saw Dark Bowser's news, and BAM! The clones literally disappeared and were invisible to the players except the Boos because they are NOT allowed to talk anymore! The Toads have believed 66% were mafia, but now all hopes were lost. Was Dark Bowser in an alliance with Dark Boo? What will happen to the clones during the night phase? NONE WILL KNOW.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: The Shattered Legacy on July 21, 2015
Rip mafia taken over by the bowser nation
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: Accj21 on July 21, 2015
The way Clone 1 said "TRUST me, I am on the town side" sounds awfully suspicious. Lynch Clone 1
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 21, 2015
Rip mafia taken over by the bowser nation
(you don't know lol
there's a high chance of a boo getting out)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: Snowy on July 21, 2015
HOW DO YOU STOP A SKIDDING CAR FROM CRASHING INTO THE MEDIAN?

ANSWER: MORE GAS.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: GrandStarGalaxy on July 21, 2015
The way Clone 1 said "TRUST me, I am on the town side" sounds awfully suspicious. Lynch Clone 1

I agree with Accj21.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 21, 2015
The way Clone 1 said "TRUST me, I am on the town side" sounds awfully suspicious. Lynch Clone 1

I agree with Accj21.
So do you lynch to vote for Clone 1?
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: GrandStarGalaxy on July 21, 2015
The way Clone 1 said "TRUST me, I am on the town side" sounds awfully suspicious. Lynch Clone 1

I agree with Accj21.
So do you lynch to vote for Clone 1?
yes.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: NintendoFan on July 21, 2015
Alright, well i'm just gonna lynch Clone 3.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: SputnicK on July 22, 2015
I am conflicted... I lynch Clone 1.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 22, 2015
The way Clone 1 said "TRUST me, I am on the town side" sounds awfully suspicious. Lynch Clone 1
It does, but Bowser498 probably did it on purpose (IMO).
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 22, 2015
The way Clone 1 said "TRUST me, I am on the town side" sounds awfully suspicious. Lynch Clone 1
It does, but Bowser498 probably did it on purpose (IMO).
I mean, he did that on purpose to make us think he's guitly, but finally he's not. I'm not sure but it would be possible. Anyway, he's the next one I'll vote for, it's pretty sure.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: GrandStarGalaxy on July 22, 2015
The way Clone 1 said "TRUST me, I am on the town side" sounds awfully suspicious. Lynch Clone 1
It does, but Bowser498 probably did it on purpose (IMO).
I mean, he did that on purpose to make us think he's guitly, but finally he's not. I'm not sure but it would be possible. Anyway, he's the next one I'll vote for, it's pretty sure.

He could have done the same thing with Clone 3.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 6)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
Hahahaha! Tied it is! Because of that, Day 6 will be no lynch! bwahahaha!

Day 6 Votes:
Clone 1: 4 (Clone 3, Accj21, Everyday Luma, SputnicK)
Clone 3: 4 (RobinFTW, Clone 1, Bossblitz88, NFan)

BTW, the person who rejoins will join on Day 7.

Day 6:
As the day progressed, the votes between Clones 1 and 3 changed like a switch turning on and off. In the end, it was literally a tie. Because of this, no lynch was made. Towards the end of the day, the cloud was near 8 feet away from the castle! What would happen if the cloud reached the castle? Only time would tell.
It is now Night 6. Anybody with night actions, please send me them. Remember, no talking unless you are dead!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Night 6)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
Night 6:
Everybody was sleeping, but some people had a tough time, that one of them had to take a melatonin! Though, in the morning, all seemed well. The two clones, Accj21, Luma, NFan, SputnicK, Bossblitz, and Robin? Wait a sec, where was Robin? Everybody went downstairs to prepare some breakfast, when they saw Robin cooking their breakfast FOR THEM! How nice! ;)
While Robin was passing out pancakes, he collapsed. Clone 1 said "8-5 9-19 4-5-1-4". Clone 3 then translated that to "He is dead". But how could they talk again? None will know.
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

It is now Day 7. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Now it's time for the winner's rejoining ceremony!
Spoiler (click to show/hide)
Spoiler: Winner Story! (click to show/hide)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 22, 2015
Nuuuuuuu I died! X| Just when I got an interesting result... *Slam the table* about the person who incarnate the role of KING BOO!
After 6 nights of investigation, I finally discovered the Mafia's leader.
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

I gotta admit, I never thought you were guilty, but now it's too late to hide...
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
EDIT: PLEASE DO NOT START LYNCHING UNTIL I GET RAF'S ROLE!
(I will edit this post when I do)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Garrulous on July 22, 2015
I swear, this whole game has just become elaborate favoritist fanfiction now.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: The Shattered Legacy on July 22, 2015
Inb4 the game never ends

"Thanks for signing up!!!" - Bowser 2015
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
@SL and Garrulous:

Of course the game is going to end. Just because it's longer with more events doesn't mean it's not mafia. Mafia also relies on creativity, you know!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: MattC on July 22, 2015
No, Mafia relies on good game balance and role playing and problem solving from the participants. None of that has been demonstrated in this game and all you did on Day 6 was make it even more convoluted. You have too many roles, you're not following your own rules (http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=15211.msg297552#msg297552), you keep interfering and adding stupid and unnecessary crap, you decided to add yourself into the game on both sides, and to top it all off you just let Robin ruin the game entirely. Great work.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Vipsoccermaster on July 22, 2015
No, Mafia relies on good game balance and role playing and problem solving from the participants. None of that has been demonstrated in this game and all you did on Day 6 was make it even more convoluted. You have too many roles, you're not following your own rules (http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=15211.msg297552#msg297552), you keep interfering and adding stupid and unnecessary crap, you decided to add yourself into the game on both sides, and to top it all off you just let Robin ruin the game entirely. Great work.
This. To put it simply, this whole mafia game was run extremely poorly. It's not how a Mafia game works. It was awful. Much awful than mafia games that Slacker and Yoshiman ran.

Bowser498, you have a lot to learn if you want to run a proper Mafia game. But this does not show that you are capable of hosting a proper Mafia game.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
No, Mafia relies on good game balance and role playing and problem solving from the participants. None of that has been demonstrated in this game and all you did on Day 6 was make it even more convoluted. You have too many roles, you're not following your own rules (http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=15211.msg297552#msg297552), you keep interfering and adding stupid and unnecessary crap, you decided to add yourself into the game on both sides, and to top it all off you just let Robin ruin the game entirely. Great work.

Excuse me, but do you see all the comments below from the participants? There weren't as many as you think. Toad (and S.T.), Mario, Luigi, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo, King Boo, and possibly Toadette.
Look at Yoshiman's. He had 8 different roles for 13 people.
And what you call "stupid and unnecessary crap" is actually daily twists. I added these to make the game more interesting than a typical mafia game. If everything is just doctor, nurse, townies, and mafia, it is extremely boring. Do you see the contestants complaining? No. They are enjoying this activity while it lasts. Just because it's longer and there are more twists doesn't mean it's bad. So what if we're on Day 7 by now? People are ENJOYING the game. The only people I see complaining are the people who aren't playing. I wonder why... And I'm not saying complaining, but complaining in a harsh way. If you say it nicer, I might actually change it. If you don't like the thread, just ignore it. You're not part of the game, so what's the big deal? Don't forget the majority of people here are newcomers. They aren't 100% experts and need some help... People need to have fun you know...
RobinFTW was the cop. He had the right BY ME to say whatever he wanted.
btw, did you even see your link? It is irrelevant to the rules of the game.
Matt, the clones were there for a reason. They don't affect the actual game except that they are extra people.

This. To put it simply, this whole mafia game was run extremely poorly. It's not how a Mafia game works. It was awful. Much awful than mafia games that Slacker and Yoshiman ran.

Bowser498, you have a lot to learn if you want to run a proper Mafia game. But this does not show that you are capable of hosting a proper Mafia game.

Bolded part is not true in several ways. Correct roles, people have been following rules, etc. I have played mafia before, and I know.

It is okay to give criticism, but PLEASE don't say it like you're acting mean. (both)It makes me really p***** and makes me feel like I have put all this time for nothing. I have seen flaws in other previous mafia games, but nobody decided to point them out, such as a certain # of percent of people confirming their role. This is JUST my opinion, but I believe this is the best thing to do.

I am sorry if I had to offend anybody in this post, but I am just stating my opinion in a non-hurtful way.
If I have to delete comments, I will for being rude/disrespectful


CONTESTANTS,  I will allow you to choose. I am actually planning to do a BETTER version (very similar plot) of this in early-mid August after Accj's finishes. Vote either:
1. Continue the game and also make one in August
2. Quit the game now, have Accj's start immediately, and make another one in August. ONLY CONTESTANTS DECIDE.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: BossBlitz on July 22, 2015
Quit. I've been here for less than seven days, and even with the twists, I'm bored.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
VOTES:
Quit: I (BossBlitz88)
Keep: I (SputnicK)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: SputnicK on July 22, 2015
No, Mafia relies on good game balance and role playing and problem solving from the participants. None of that has been demonstrated in this game and all you did on Day 6 was make it even more convoluted. You have too many roles, you're not following your own rules (http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=15211.msg297552#msg297552), you keep interfering and adding stupid and unnecessary crap, you decided to add yourself into the game on both sides, and to top it all off you just let Robin ruin the game entirely. Great work.
This. To put it simply, this whole mafia game was run extremely poorly. It's not how a Mafia game works. It was awful. Much awful than mafia games that Slacker and Yoshiman ran.

Bowser498, you have a lot to learn if you want to run a proper Mafia game. But this does not show that you are capable of hosting a proper Mafia game.
OK that is the rudest crap I have heard in the long time. Who the hell cares if he's not following "traditional" rules, this is a freaking Mario Party forum and it's his board. If he wants to run it differently, then I say let him do it.

Even if he did mess a lot of things up, the way you said it was extremely insulting and completely uncalled for. Seriously as moderators I would expect you to have a level of care towards other peoples feelings.

I really enjoyed this game and appreciate Bowser498 for spending his time to host it.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
No, Mafia relies on good game balance and role playing and problem solving from the participants. None of that has been demonstrated in this game and all you did on Day 6 was make it even more convoluted. You have too many roles, you're not following your own rules (http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=15211.msg297552#msg297552), you keep interfering and adding stupid and unnecessary crap, you decided to add yourself into the game on both sides, and to top it all off you just let Robin ruin the game entirely. Great work.
This. To put it simply, this whole mafia game was run extremely poorly. It's not how a Mafia game works. It was awful. Much awful than mafia games that Slacker and Yoshiman ran.

Bowser498, you have a lot to learn if you want to run a proper Mafia game. But this does not show that you are capable of hosting a proper Mafia game.
OK that is the rudest crap I have heard in the long time. Who the hell cares if he's not following "traditional" rules, this is a freaking Mario Party forum and it's his board. If he wants to run it differently, then I say let him do it.

Even if he did mess a lot of things up, the way you said it was extremely insulting and completely uncalled for. Seriously as moderators I would expect you to have a level of care towards other peoples feelings.

I really enjoyed this game and appreciate Bowser498 for spending his time to host it.
^Agreed. Glad you're happy!
Another thing: If you don't like it, JUST ignore it. It's not going to affect you if you're not part of it.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: SpiderStaryu on July 22, 2015
Nuuuuuuu I died! X| Just when I got an interesting result... *Slam the table* about the person who incarnate the role of KING BOO!
After 6 nights of investigation, I finally discovered the Mafia's leader.
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

I gotta admit, I never thought you were guilty, but now it's too late to hide...
Just future advice if you're in Mafia games in the future; you don't have the right to reveal what you know when you've been killed. You're dead, you have no right to talk anymore about what you may or may not know. It's completely unfair to the mafia side, because you, as a dead player, just guaranteed the mafia's demise. I'm just letting you know in case you were confused on this, and didn't know why it was wrong.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Ether on July 22, 2015
really makes you wish you were robbed of your computer by an actual mafia
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 22, 2015
I don't think it's a bad mafia game... I don't have any experience, but I find this game pretty fun. I think adding twists like this is fine. Yeah, it's not a traditional Mafia game, but what's the matter? I don't get why everybody is bashing on Bowser498... I probably missed something somewhere, but eh.
Nuuuuuuu I died! X| Just when I got an interesting result... *Slam the table* about the person who incarnate the role of KING BOO!
After 6 nights of investigation, I finally discovered the Mafia's leader.
Spoiler (click to show/hide)

I gotta admit, I never thought you were guilty, but now it's too late to hide...
Just future advice if you're in Mafia games in the future; you don't have the right to reveal what you know when you've been killed. You're dead, you have no right to talk anymore about what you may or may not know. It's completely unfair to the mafia side, because you, as a dead player, just guaranteed the mafia's demise. I'm just letting you know in case you were confused on this, and didn't know why it was wrong.
I appreciate the advice, but I know all that. In this game though, the moderator allowed me, so yeah, but I admit it's kinda of cheap from me.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
Sorry for saying this but I feel like I need to redo this another time---1-2 weeks after Accj's ends.
Accj, you can start yours now if you want to.
NOTE: I will be using the same thread and will be deleting all the posts except for the first one---sorry but it must be done.
SIGN-UPS will be in the sign-up thread so we can redo this soon. They will end in a couple of weeks!
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: MattC on July 22, 2015
Excuse me, but do you see all the comments below from the participants? There weren't as many as you think. Toad (and S.T.), Mario, Luigi, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo, King Boo, and possibly Toadette.
Look at Yoshiman's. He had 8 different roles for 13 people.

So far I see one guy quitting and another defending you.

Yoshiman's Mafia was unique but it made sense. It was thought out from the beginning, you were after a single person and the role distribution was fair. You had 9 roles for 11 people. Stop acting like the Super Toad is the same as Toad. Having an extra life is extremely valuable in the game like this. You really didn't think the roles through the the beginning, but honestly, that would've been okay if it was just that.

And what you call "stupid and unnecessary crap" is actually daily twists. I added these to make the game more interesting than a typical mafia game. If everything is just doctor, nurse, townies, and mafia, it is extremely boring. Do you see the contestants complaining? No. They are enjoying this activity while it lasts.
Again, you're not thinking through with these twists or whatever. The whole point of a mafia game is for the participants to eliminate the bad guys before the bad guys can eliminate them. Your twists really don't add to that. The day four one was... some vague message from an outside player, I guess? The day four one was a mushroom from another outside player. Didn't really add anything to the story. Day five was the survey which implied that players were supposed to explore the castle or something, I guess that should've been addressed earlier? And day six I addressed in my first post. All you did was make everything more confusing. What's the purpose of adding clones or whatever? Why are you adding someone who's probably never played the game before? Why are you bringing someone back? It almost seems like you were trying to duct tape the criticisms about the town being too powerful.

To be really honest about the participants, I don't think they know what they're doing. They lynched Rafal because he made a joke. WiiUFan and RLWilliams just kind of gave up. No one is actually giving any depth to why they're suspecting and lynching people. They're probably not complaining because they've never participated in a mafia game before.

The only people I see complaining are the people who aren't playing. I wonder why...
There are a lot of people here who want to play Mafia but don't want to start another while one is running, it's a respect thing. We're complaining because you're not doing a good job running it. I think you should play in a few before you decide to host one.

And I'm not saying complaining, but complaining in a harsh way. If you say it nicer, I might actually change it. If you don't like the thread, just ignore it. You're not part of the game, so what's the big deal?
Jesus, learn to take a hit. You really need to get off your high horse here. You're going to learn that people are going to come down on you for the things you say and do, and you're "I have an opinion" and "just ignore it" rebuttals aren't going to work. I get that your a proud person who holds themselves highly, but I am too. I'm coming down on you harsh because I think you need someone to be tough on you. Not everyone is going to sugarcoat their criticism.

Don't forget the majority of people here are newcomers. They aren't 100% experts and need some help...
This is one of the base reasons why the game didn't do well. I already addressed why.

RobinFTW was the cop. He had the right BY ME to say whatever he wanted.
btw, did you even see your link? It is irrelevant to the rules of the game.
Matt, the clones were there for a reason. They don't affect the actual game except that they are extra people.
1. I get that, sure, but he told everyone who King Boo was. Who do you think they're going to lynch? He was Mario too, so that means that people are going to take his word for it. If he's right, the game is pretty much over (because EL, your clones or Rafal are the last Boo(s). If he's wrong, he just wasted a the town's day and got one of them killed. Ergo, it ruined the game.

2. EL didn't actually bold his vote to lynch the clone. Your first rules says he had to. He broke the rule.

3. Adding extra people to the game affects the game.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: RobinFTW on July 22, 2015
Sorry for saying this but I feel like I need to redo this another time---1-2 weeks after Accj's ends.
Accj, you can start yours now if you want to.
NOTE: I will be using the same thread and will be deleting all the posts except for the first one---sorry but it must be done.
SIGN-UPS will be in the sign-up thread so we can redo this soon. They will end in a couple of weeks!
So you're canceling this one? Oh wait nvm.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Day 7)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 22, 2015
Sorry for saying this but I feel like I need to redo this another time---1-2 weeks after Accj's ends.
Accj, you can start yours now if you want to.
NOTE: I will be using the same thread and will be deleting all the posts except for the first one---sorry but it must be done.
SIGN-UPS will be in the sign-up thread so we can redo this soon. They will end in a couple of weeks!
So you're canceling this one? Oh wait nvm.
This one, but I'm starting a new one in 1-2 weeks, but after Accj's ends. Until then, I will create a storyline (same place), new roles, etc.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: Yoshiman222 on July 22, 2015
Excuse me, but do you see all the comments below from the participants? There weren't as many as you think. Toad (and S.T.), Mario, Luigi, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo, King Boo, and possibly Toadette.
Look at Yoshiman's. He had 8 different roles for 13 people.

So far I see one guy quitting and another defending you.

Yoshiman's Mafia was unique but it made sense. It was thought out from the beginning, you were after a single person and the role distribution was fair. You had 9 roles for 11 people. Stop acting like the Super Toad is the same as Toad. Having an extra life is extremely valuable in the game like this. You really didn't think the roles through the the beginning, but honestly, that would've been okay if it was just that.
I just wana point from this that I typically take about a few months to plan these things out from start to finish - when certain events happen and how powerful each role gets. It's not an easy task to balance such things while adding new things (especially since I've tried adding what are known as ba*erd roles, which are very game-breaking roles. Revival is in fact known to be one such of these).

If you want help, there's an old topic in the archives that helped me set up my first game when I did. (http://www.mariopartylegacy.com/forum/index.php?topic=9719.0)

I suggest if it's your first time hosting, start with a basic game to help you understand what it takes to host such a game. It really is different to host than play, so starting off with something easy will greatly help with later on. Fyi - a basic game consists of the simplest roles from the Mafia,  Townie, Cop, Doctor, and sometimes a Godfather (with a few exceptions including I think a serial killer and some other town role...? Look for the flash animation in that link I posted if you wana know in full details).
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: The Shattered Legacy on July 23, 2015
Please read the post as I think it will be useful not just for mafia, but just overall conducting yourself. If you don't, fine, but that's your loss.



Okay, let's analyze the game and mafia generally as objectively as possible (btw I'm in general agreement with Matt and Yoshiman's comments):

>Mafia is meant to be a game focused on observing social interactions between players, and observing patterns or other traits of others to formulate arguments as to their innocence/guilt. Naturally, beginners won't be as skilled in directing conversation and scumhunting, but just expecting everyone to direct the flow of game for you, or jumping on one person and no-one providing any further arguments for OR against and bandwagoning, doesn't really allow this crucial aspect of the game to come out.

>Mafia pits a generally uninformed town majority against an informed mafia minority; i.e. the town do not know (excluding investigative power roles) who is mafia, but mafia most certainly do. This was achieved reasonably okay in this game with 8 vs 3.

>The existence of power roles of any sort on the town should offset the mafia's ability for consistent kills, but not to the point where mafia can get walled out by protection and then outed through investigative roleclaim/reports.
In this game, we have:
Town: a cop, a character who is effectively a mason with the cop, a doctor, two 1 hit bulletproofs, and a 1-use unkillable, and two vanilla townies.
Mafia: two vanilla mafia, one who finalizes kills, and a random mafia aligned serial killer-like role (one-shot only) that does NOT have a certain kill if they use it, AND for some reason cannot vote for that day phase.

Town have up to 4 characters who can block a kill, mafia have up to 2 but their kills can all be blocked. In addition, every day, two characters can confirm the identity of a town/mafia, and on the chance a Bowser uses the kill move, they automatically cast suspicion on themselves because they can't vote to set up a kill.

To me this means that town are power heavy and as long as cop and mason/cop claim early, doc can continue to protect them and the mafia will probably be all killed off.

How I would change the roles:
Get rid of Luigi, replace with either a Toad or perhaps an Insane Cop (reversed town/mafia reads) but tbh one investigative role is enough
Lose one Super Toad and replace with a Toad
King Boo should be a godfather character (appears innocent to Mario)
Bowser should have a kill that cannot be healed/blocked, and they should not lose their vote penalty

>Unless the events do not impact on gameplay, they should be disclosed before the game even starts.
I'll elaborate on clones, hosts joining in the game, and revivals later, but for a game focused on social interaction and pattern recognition is significantly hurt when random factors like this appear. "Twists" to the game make it deviate away from mafia to the point where this isn't mafia, but a game inspired by mafia but is actually "host determines what they feel like for the rules and players will have to adapt". This isn't fun (I'd argue that the players in this game simply don't understand what mafia is MEANT to be about and thus didn't really mind, but from the perspective of those who play mafia as it's meant to be run and enjoy it, it's painful to see).
Also, it's only boring when no-one talks. =P

>A host should never join their own game in any playable capacity.
I don't care if the clones are supposed to not know other players' alignment. The host behind them does, and can manipulate results at will. For all I know, Clone 1 and Clone 3 could both be mafia, but once Clone 1 gets majority, the host could say "actually you killed a town player!"

>Adding player numbers into a game will distort the probabilities for determining LYLO/MYLO scenarios.
In most cases, adding a mafia player, even if a townie is added as well, will greatly favor mafia as they can now kill less people before gaining 50%+ of the player count. Even with clones.

>Revival is dangerous, even if the player's role is changed, as their existing knowledge of previous events can be potentially abused, and also contributes to player count issues as above.
The most extreme examples can be when an ex-investigative role (especially detective) becomes mafia. If they have a good index of suspicion as to which player has what role when they were town, they could tell their now mafia buddies this and secure a crucial power role kill. Also, players in game generally don't change their opinion of a recently revived player in enough time in the case that said player has changed alignment. You should never continue reviving players because the reality of mafia is not everyone will be able to be involved from start to finish - if you want that, go play The Resistance or something.

>Big big one: NEVER allow players to reveal any information they know on death (unless you are on EpicMafia and have Wills on, but those are night only, lol)
This just breaks the game. Cop dead? "I know x y z are town and a b c are mafia" Doc dead? "I healed l m n"

>Remember, the more information is known via power roles or host deciding to reveal them, the more likely town will win. Consider roles that confuse information received for a more complex but less broken role setup.
Town are balanced despite superior numbers because they are uninformed. Don't have too many investigative roles unless mafia can counter that with killing ability, blocking ability or investigation of their own (the latter is absurdly powerful). Throwing a godfather and a miller in already makes cop less powerful, so consider that for another game.



Subjective comments:

"Mafia relies on creativity" - it relies on players being willing to talk, question each other, and generally interact on a deeper social level than what this game demonstrated. It's not really an activity where you can no-brain it and go 'today I vote x, tomorrow y'. Creativity should be limited to a different role setup or starting on night instead of day. It shouldn't depend on day-to-day events just to make it seem interesting.

"8 roles for 13 people" - quality and not quantity of the roles is important. As I stated above, dumping loads of defensive power roles on town really shuts mafia out and they have to work extra hard and just hope town kill themselves. Adding new players, presumably to further town's advantage, is poorly thought out.

"make the game more interesting than a typical mafia game" - imo this game isn't mafia any more because we have these dummy roles, host imvolvement in the game itself, and revival which doesn't appear balanced to the town/mafia numbers. Role info reveal is probably a lesser crime but it's the nail in the coffin.

"If everything is just doctor, nurse, townies, and mafia, it is extremely boring" - please refer to Matt's comment about player participation. Which for the record is NOT "oh I vote x" "yeah I vote x too" "cool". To me, that is boring.

"the clones were there for a reason. They don't affect the actual game except that they are extra people" - see above. People make the mafia. Adding more people, including dummies, changes the outcome because there are simply more people and more variables involved.

"I have seen flaws in other previous mafia games, but nobody decided to point them out, such as a certain # of percent of people confirming their role" - this isn't a flaw. It's called discussion. People are allowed to challenge role claims, and in fact higher level play even in the standard 2 maf vs 5 town (with doc and cop as part of town) counterclaiming is really important as a good mafia counterclaim can sway people into voting wrongly and giving mafia victory. Mafia is not a game of just accepting everything that happens and then not thinking about the alternative scenarios.

"If I have to delete comments, I will for being rude/disrespectful" - I don't know if the viewpoint of a single person is the appropriate measure by which to measure what is rude or disrespectful, but okay

@SputnicK "Seriously as moderators I would expect you to have a level of care towards other peoples feelings" - VIP is not a mod, and this is the internet. Feelings be damned. In seriousness, to quote Bowser himself, people are entitled to their opinions regardless of how hurtful, and like Bowser said himself, don't like it? Ignore. (Ignore doesn't mean delete btw Bowser) Also, I have enough faith in the mods here to recognise an actual hurtful comment and deal with it appropriately.

On that note @Bowser: a comment like "No, Mafia relies on good game balance and role playing and problem solving from the participants. None of that has been demonstrated in this game and all you did on Day 6 was make it even more convoluted. You have too many roles, you're not following your own rules, you keep interfering and adding stupid and unnecessary crap, you decided to add yourself into the game on both sides, and to top it all off you just let Robin ruin the game entirely. Great work." is nowhere near grounds to cry out as being hurtful or disrespectful (unless 'crap' somehow hits your radar like it does LFan's - sorry LFan). Rather than trying to puff yourself up and reject everything, how about challenge each point in a meaningful discussion, without pushing your fixed agenda at the same time? e.g. "Why have I made the game convoluted? Please explain." "In what way was my addition of x 'crap'?" "How did I let Robin ruin the game? Shouldn't he be allowed to because I said so?" Open yourself to questioning. A wall of answers and general resistance to hear others looks incredibly arrogant. Also your definition of harsh complaints is... vague at best.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: RLWilliams3d on July 23, 2015
I would like to re-join the mafia game, Bow Wow. :)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: SputnicK on July 23, 2015
Quote
@SputnicK "Seriously as moderators I would expect you to have a level of care towards other peoples feelings" - VIP is not a mod, and this is the internet. Feelings be damned. In seriousness, to quote Bowser himself, people are entitled to their opinions regardless of how hurtful, and like Bowser said himself, don't like it? Ignore. (Ignore doesn't mean delete btw Bowser) Also, I have enough faith in the mods here to recognise an actual hurtful comment and deal with it appropriately.
While I agree that the game got convoluted near the end, the way Vip and MattC handled it did not show subtleness or respect for Bowser498 in the slightest. I guess it's less what they said, but how they said it that was over the line. There's helpful, and then there's rude. They way they said it was just rude.

While I agree that the game did not play anything like a traditional one, (I have played many mafia games before this BTW) you have to remember that this is his first try and he was probably unclear on the solid rules that must be followed. And to be honest, I still had fun. Yes I know this is the "internet" and I shouldn't expect nice behavior, but that doesn't excuse outright rudeness from the veterans here of all people. While "Feelings be damned" may be your attitudes towards the world, It certainty isn't mine so I'm sorry If I get a little frustrated by this.

I'm not arguing with your critiques, I'm just asking you to have a level of tact when displaying them.
-SputnicK
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: SmashBoo on July 23, 2015
I never participated in a Mafia game before, so I can't really say this is a better/worse game than the usual. I can't also say that it was bad, because I did have fun with it and the story or "twists" were a good addition to it I think. Count with me if you want to re-do it. However I do understand some flaws that others pointed out, but there's a difference between pointing flaws and be straight rude. I don't think people should be throwing crap all over Bowser498, it's his first time doing it, nobody's perfect at their first time and besides that I believe this game wasn't supposed to have a perfect story, perfect roles when it was planned, it was supposed to be fun, nothing more, nothing less. And what's the point of being rude, sure everyone can say whatever they want, but if you do that you'll just feed your own ego, because you don't need to be rude to criticize things y'know. I think Yoshiman did a great job in offering help, since he has a lot of experience.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: MattC on July 23, 2015
I never participated in a Mafia game before, so I can't really say this is a better/worse game than the usual. I can't also say that it was bad, because I did have fun with it and the story or "twists" were a good addition to it I think. Count with me if you want to re-do it. However I do understand some flaws that others pointed out, but there's a difference between pointing flaws and be straight rude. I don't think people should be throwing crap all over Bowser498, it's his first time doing it, nobody's perfect at their first time and besides that I believe this game wasn't supposed to have a perfect story, perfect roles when it was planned, it was supposed to be fun, nothing more, nothing less. And what's the point of being rude, sure everyone can say whatever they want, but if you do that you'll just feed your own ego, because you don't need to be rude to criticize things y'know. I think Yoshiman did a great job in offering help, since he has a lot of experience.
So you didn't read anything HJ or I posted.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: The Shattered Legacy on July 23, 2015
While I agree that the game got convoluted near the end, the way Vip and MattC handled it did not show subtleness or respect for Bowser498 in the slightest. I guess it's less what they said, but how they said it that was over the line. There's helpful, and then there's rude. They way they said it was just rude.

While I agree that the game did not play anything like a traditional one, (I have played many mafia games before this BTW) you have to remember that this is his first try and he was probably unclear on the solid rules that must be followed. And to be honest, I still had fun. Yes I know this is the "internet" and I shouldn't expect nice behavior, but that doesn't excuse outright rudeness from the veterans here of all people. While "Feelings be damned" may be your attitudes towards the world, It certainty isn't mine so I'm sorry If I get a little frustrated by this.

I'm not arguing with your critiques, I'm just asking you to have a level of tact when displaying them.
-SputnicK
Thanks for the reply. Tbh the fact I still cared to write the wall of text, and also to header the subjective section as a sort of warning, to me at least makes me feel like I still have feelings and awareness of sensitivities towards this issue. But I've had enough experience in the past to know when a situation is furile enough to pull out and just... well, not offer the luxury of feelings.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: Accj21 on July 23, 2015
My thoughts: It was fun, but confusing. I was getting ready to kick off mine, and guess what? There are 3 more people. It made for unexpected twists, which could be both good and bad. I'm still gonna play when mine is over.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: BossBlitz on July 23, 2015
You know what, I'm actually gonna stay in. If I'm filling in for Geo, might as well get the job done, bad game or not.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: Colyton on July 23, 2015
fruit pancake baguette
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: SmashBoo on July 23, 2015
I never participated in a Mafia game before, so I can't really say this is a better/worse game than the usual. I can't also say that it was bad, because I did have fun with it and the story or "twists" were a good addition to it I think. Count with me if you want to re-do it. However I do understand some flaws that others pointed out, but there's a difference between pointing flaws and be straight rude. I don't think people should be throwing crap all over Bowser498, it's his first time doing it, nobody's perfect at their first time and besides that I believe this game wasn't supposed to have a perfect story, perfect roles when it was planned, it was supposed to be fun, nothing more, nothing less. And what's the point of being rude, sure everyone can say whatever they want, but if you do that you'll just feed your own ego, because you don't need to be rude to criticize things y'know. I think Yoshiman did a great job in offering help, since he has a lot of experience.
So you didn't read anything HJ or I posted.
I did read it, but if you say so. I don't even care anymore.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: Some Edgy Wii U Fan on July 23, 2015
"STOP HATING ON MY MAFIA GAME!!!"
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 24, 2015
Just saying, but when I start the game, I will be deleting all of these posts. Sorry, but I want this thread to concentrate only on the new game.
@MattC, Yoshiman, Staryu, and Shattered Legacy: I read the posts and will take your ideas into consideration for the next game. ;)
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: The Shattered Legacy on July 24, 2015
Just saying, but when I start the game, I will be deleting all of these posts. Sorry, but I want this thread to concentrate only on the new game.
Couldn't you just make a new topic though?
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 24, 2015
Just saying, but when I start the game, I will be deleting all of these posts. Sorry, but I want this thread to concentrate only on the new game.
Couldn't you just make a new topic though?
I don't wanna waste topic room
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: MattC on July 24, 2015
Just saying, but when I start the game, I will be deleting all of these posts. Sorry, but I want this thread to concentrate only on the new game.
Couldn't you just make a new topic though?
I don't wanna waste topic room
topic room is not a thing
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: SpiderStaryu on July 24, 2015
Just saying, but when I start the game, I will be deleting all of these posts. Sorry, but I want this thread to concentrate only on the new game.
Couldn't you just make a new topic though?
I don't wanna waste topic room
You're not wasting anything. Just make a new topic for the new game once it starts, and just lock this.
Title: Re: MK Mafia: Peach's Castle -GAME- (Cancelled for a few weeks until Accj's ends)
Post by: Bowser498 on July 24, 2015
Just saying, but when I start the game, I will be deleting all of these posts. Sorry, but I want this thread to concentrate only on the new game.
Couldn't you just make a new topic though?
I don't wanna waste topic room
You're not wasting anything. Just make a new topic for the new game once it starts, and just lock this.
Oh okay
(I can't lock the topic btw :-\)
Well, then please put this in the archives so it doesn't stay in with others...