Was Toadette the best addition?

Status
Not open for further replies.
SpiderStaryu said:
Do I think she was the absolute best? No. But she still was interesting nonetheless, though I started to dislike her in MP9 because for some reason, she was just so annoying... =P No disrespect to the Toadette fans here.

Toad, Boo, and Koopa Kid were probably my favorite additions and the ones I was the most excited for. :D
Wait, started to disliked her in Mario Party 9? Toadette didn't even appear in Mario Party 9.
 
Vipsoccermaster said:
SpiderStaryu said:
Do I think she was the absolute best? No. But she still was interesting nonetheless, though I started to dislike her in MP9 because for some reason, she was just so annoying... =P No disrespect to the Toadette fans here.

Toad, Boo, and Koopa Kid were probably my favorite additions and the ones I was the most excited for. :D
Wait, started to disliked her in Mario Party 9? Toadette didn't even appear in Mario Party 9.
I meant MP8, of course.
 
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Daisy, Wario, Waluigi, Rosalina, Birdo, and Yoshi are all more popular than her and probably placed higher than her in popularity.
I wouldn't consider Birdo a popular character. I hardly ever see any Birdo fans, and the people who don't mind it, hardly ever use it. It probably has more haters than likers. At least Toadette is actually used and appreciated by a lot more people.
  Ya am I the only one who does not like rosalina SHE is NOT a MP player!!!!! Toadette is far better
 
yoshi1999 said:
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Daisy, Wario, Waluigi, Rosalina, Birdo, and Yoshi are all more popular than her and probably placed higher than her in popularity.
I wouldn't consider Birdo a popular character. I hardly ever see any Birdo fans, and the people who don't mind it, hardly ever use it. It probably has more haters than likers. At least Toadette is actually used and appreciated by a lot more people.
  Ya am I the only one who does not like rosalina SHE is NOT a MP player!!!!! Toadette is far better
This.

I think Toadette is pretty good.
 
TheAntiGuy said:
yoshi1999 said:
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Daisy, Wario, Waluigi, Rosalina, Birdo, and Yoshi are all more popular than her and probably placed higher than her in popularity.
I wouldn't consider Birdo a popular character. I hardly ever see any Birdo fans, and the people who don't mind it, hardly ever use it. It probably has more haters than likers. At least Toadette is actually used and appreciated by a lot more people.
  Ya am I the only one who does not like rosalina SHE is NOT a MP player!!!!! Toadette is far better
This.

I think Toadette is pretty good.

I know many Birdo fans BTW


I don't hate Rosalina, but only think she is ok. She seems out of place in Mario just a bit, but she is deffinitaly NOT MP material.
 
★Plum★ said:
TheAntiGuy said:
yoshi1999 said:
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Daisy, Wario, Waluigi, Rosalina, Birdo, and Yoshi are all more popular than her and probably placed higher than her in popularity.
I wouldn't consider Birdo a popular character. I hardly ever see any Birdo fans, and the people who don't mind it, hardly ever use it. It probably has more haters than likers. At least Toadette is actually used and appreciated by a lot more people.
  Ya am I the only one who does not like rosalina SHE is NOT a MP player!!!!! Toadette is far better
This.

I think Toadette is pretty good.

I know many Birdo fans BTW


I don't hate Rosalina, but only think she is ok. She seems out of place in Mario just a bit, but she is deffinitaly NOT MP material.
Every character made by Nintendo has fans, It's not rocket science. It still has more dislikers than likers though.

The only reason why I agree that Rosalina is not MP material is because she would over power them and always win. ;)
 
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
TheAntiGuy said:
yoshi1999 said:
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Daisy, Wario, Waluigi, Rosalina, Birdo, and Yoshi are all more popular than her and probably placed higher than her in popularity.
I wouldn't consider Birdo a popular character. I hardly ever see any Birdo fans, and the people who don't mind it, hardly ever use it. It probably has more haters than likers. At least Toadette is actually used and appreciated by a lot more people.
  Ya am I the only one who does not like rosalina SHE is NOT a MP player!!!!! Toadette is far better
This.

I think Toadette is pretty good.

I know many Birdo fans BTW


I don't hate Rosalina, but only think she is ok. She seems out of place in Mario just a bit, but she is deffinitaly NOT MP material.
Every character made by Nintendo has fans, It's not rocket science. It still has more dislikers than likers though.

The only reason why I agree that Rosalina is not MP material is because she would over power them and always win. ;)

I just think you disslike her, so you say she has no fans and everyone disslikes her. :p

She has more likers than haters and with Rosalina...no. She isn't MP material becuase she wouldn't fit in with the rest of them.
 
★Plum★ said:
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
TheAntiGuy said:
yoshi1999 said:
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Daisy, Wario, Waluigi, Rosalina, Birdo, and Yoshi are all more popular than her and probably placed higher than her in popularity.
I wouldn't consider Birdo a popular character. I hardly ever see any Birdo fans, and the people who don't mind it, hardly ever use it. It probably has more haters than likers. At least Toadette is actually used and appreciated by a lot more people.
  Ya am I the only one who does not like rosalina SHE is NOT a MP player!!!!! Toadette is far better
This.

I think Toadette is pretty good.

I know many Birdo fans BTW


I don't hate Rosalina, but only think she is ok. She seems out of place in Mario just a bit, but she is deffinitaly NOT MP material.
Every character made by Nintendo has fans, It's not rocket science. It still has more dislikers than likers though.

The only reason why I agree that Rosalina is not MP material is because she would over power them and always win. ;)

I just think you disslike her, so you say she has no fans and everyone disslikes her. :p

She has more likers than haters and with Rosalina...no. She isn't MP material becuase she wouldn't fit in with the rest of them.
http://www.fanpop.com/spots/mario/picks/results/667122/like-birdo
Even though it's a small poll (the best I could find) it's clear that Birdo is disliked most. On top of that, a lot of the likers came from Yoshi, the most popular character. Yes, both of our opinions are biased, but it's not hard for me to find comments of those who dislike Birdo. I don't even hear people talking about Waluigi as often as Birdo. Also, You're saying that Rosalina wouldn't fit in a game full of humans and moving, talking animals and fungi? She is after all, as you say, a remodeled version of Peach.

Anyway, Toadette is my favourite fungi and I hope she is in the next Mario game. I do occasionally play as her, though she's not my main character.
 
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
TheAntiGuy said:
yoshi1999 said:
Toblet said:
★Plum★ said:
Mario, Luigi, Bowser, Peach, Daisy, Wario, Waluigi, Rosalina, Birdo, and Yoshi are all more popular than her and probably placed higher than her in popularity.
I wouldn't consider Birdo a popular character. I hardly ever see any Birdo fans, and the people who don't mind it, hardly ever use it. It probably has more haters than likers. At least Toadette is actually used and appreciated by a lot more people.
  Ya am I the only one who does not like rosalina SHE is NOT a MP player!!!!! Toadette is far better
This.

I think Toadette is pretty good.

I know many Birdo fans BTW


I don't hate Rosalina, but only think she is ok. She seems out of place in Mario just a bit, but she is deffinitaly NOT MP material.
Every character made by Nintendo has fans, It's not rocket science. It still has more dislikers than likers though.

The only reason why I agree that Rosalina is not MP material is because she would over power them and always win. ;)

I just think you disslike her, so you say she has no fans and everyone disslikes her. :p

She has more likers than haters and with Rosalina...no. She isn't MP material becuase she wouldn't fit in with the rest of them.
http://www.fanpop.com/spots/mario/picks/results/667122/like-birdo
Even though it's a small poll (the best I could find) it's clear that Birdo is disliked most. On top of that, a lot of the likers came from Yoshi, the most popular character. Yes, both of our opinions are biased, but it's not hard for me to find comments of those who dislike Birdo. I don't even hear people talking about Waluigi as often as Birdo. Also, You're saying that Rosalina wouldn't fit in a game full of humans and moving, talking animals and fungi? She is after all, as you say, a remodeled version of Peach.

Anyway, Toadette is my favourite fungi and I hope she is in the next Mario game. I do occasionally play as her, though she's not my main character.

Yes we are both biased, but Waluigi isn't useless as a character (if Toadette's appearance in TTYD counts as being a more main character then Waluigi appearing in M&L counts to) and Birdo isn't a complete hated sucker dino thing.


ANYWAY! The reason I say Rosalina wouldn't fit in is becuase the characters in Mario Party act cartoony and Rosalina is to serious and passive of a character to play something like MP.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top