Jinx's Comparisons #40 - Professor Layton vs Phoenix Wright (Requested by TT)

[MQJinx]

A Melodic Kappa Production
Two crime investigators now face off to see who is the better one. Who will get the gold?

Let's find out.
RockMan no Constancy - Stage Start (Stage Start)

VS

Category 1: Appearance

Spoiler

Appearance-wise, I'd say this point goes to Phoenix, because people want their investigators to look serious at the job, and Phoenix looks more serious.

0

1

 

[MQJinx]

Category 2: Actions

Spoiler

This point goes to Phoenix Wright, because he solved more cases than Professor Layton's 7 cases he solved.

0

2

 

[MQJinx]

Category 3: Personality

Spoiler

Both of these characters are considerate towards others, but this point goes to the person who I can hang out with more pleasure, and Professor Layton is calm and cool.

1

2

 

[MQJinx]

Category 4: Style

Spoiler

Both of these characters have some interesting styles, though this point goes to Layton because his way of solving cases through puzzles is rather unique.

2

2

 

[MQJinx]

Category 5: Motivations

Spoiler

Both of these characters are motivated to help their defendants, though Phoenix takes this point because he will not back down once his mind is made up.

FINAL SCORE
2

3

The conclusion: Professor Layton is a good detective, but Phoenix Wright is more interesting for me and keeps me anticipating on what he might do next.

WINNER: PHOENIX WRIGHT

 

[Darkboo007]

Agreed with this!

 

[ttwashere]

Loved reading this. I think Nick deserves a close win as well.